International Law in My Court?
The debate continues...
Today, the Washington Post ran a story on two recent Supreme Court decisions on the role of foreign law in the U.S. court system. The Court ruled yesterday that foreign law doesn't apply for those convicted of gun charges abroad, but does apply when citizens try to screw foreign governments out of tax money. Hmmm, let's see if I get this right. Foreign violent crime convictions not okay in courts, white collar crime is.
Although, living in Kazakhstan, I can understand the doubt our courts would place on criminal convictions from foreign courts when so many are used as politician's weapons. But then why allow them at all?
These rulings, on the heels of the Court's ruling in Roper v. Simmons, based largely on international law, are certainly not the last of the debate on the role of foreign law and international law in our courts. (Click here for Dahlia Lithwick's take on Roper...)
Today, the Washington Post ran a story on two recent Supreme Court decisions on the role of foreign law in the U.S. court system. The Court ruled yesterday that foreign law doesn't apply for those convicted of gun charges abroad, but does apply when citizens try to screw foreign governments out of tax money. Hmmm, let's see if I get this right. Foreign violent crime convictions not okay in courts, white collar crime is.
Although, living in Kazakhstan, I can understand the doubt our courts would place on criminal convictions from foreign courts when so many are used as politician's weapons. But then why allow them at all?
These rulings, on the heels of the Court's ruling in Roper v. Simmons, based largely on international law, are certainly not the last of the debate on the role of foreign law and international law in our courts. (Click here for Dahlia Lithwick's take on Roper...)


